I don't understand Marvin Lewis, he's only had 4 winning season's and lost all 4
of his playoff games.
I'm not crazy about Jeff Fisher either but he did lose in a SuperBowl, BUT he's had a lot of down years.
Andy Reid won more (I think) and has more playoff wins.
Ok you said you were spliting hairs; so their's no problem with your picks. I've just been an Andy Reid fan for awhile, although I hated the Eagles.
I'm not considering their entire resumes Cyril. I'm really only looking at the last 5 or 6 years when I'm making that list. And I think the last 5 years of Reid's tenure, he's been nothing special. Not since 2008 were the Eagles really a contender. They were somewhat scary in 2010 (as I considered them better than us at the time), but they just really fell apart in 2011 and 2012, and I have to dock Reid quite a bit for that.
Since 2009, the Bengals have won 33 games under Lewis. The Eagles won 34 under Reid. The Bengals went to the playoffs 3 times, while the Eagles only twice.
But to be honest, I was a bit reluctant to include Lewis on that list, but it was the much greater success Cincy has had the past 2 years over Philly that pushed me to do it.