I'd keep Hall around because he's a better alternative than really anybody else we have. I'd like to see some real competition at safety this summer. Scott is out until at least the end of July according to estimates, so he'll probably only be limited to be able to go full speed for half of training camp.
Hall and Carpenter are decent options in his stead, and I'd bring in Schulters as well. Heard, Coady, and McCadam all have starting experience, and the hope is Pruitt is going to make improvement this summer as well.
I think Scott is the only one guaranteed a roster spot, and I'd like to see 3 or 4 others battle it out for the remaining spots.
Honestly, I'm not too psyched having either Hall or Carpenter in the starting lineup this year. But in the past they've proven to be competent starters, and either would make a pretty solid dime back (Carpenter is better in that role IMO), with the possibility that Scott & Schultesr are the starters. Then we can keep among Heard, Coady, and Pruitt the best 1 or 2 special teamers, depending on how the rest of the roster falls into place.
Hall deserves as much a chance if not more than Carpenter to earn playing time this year.
"Vincere scis, Hannibal, victoria uti nescis" -- Maharbal, 216 B.C.E.