It is currently Fri Sep 19, 2014 4:58 am

All times are UTC - 4 hours [ DST ]





Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 7 posts ] 
Author Message
 Post subject: Pudge's Positional Rankings
PostPosted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 4:56 pm 
Offline
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
User avatar

Joined: Thu Dec 23, 2004 3:03 pm
Posts: 25930
Location: North Carolina
I made some changes, and adding some preliminary grades to some of these guys. No exact science (one could say I pulled them out of my butt) to the numbers, just based off a gut feeling about the guy.

You can see an explanation of what the numbers mean by clicking here: viewtopic.php?f=3&t=10924


* - indicates a player that I've seen some of, but haven't finalized my grading for them because have a bit more tape to watch

QUARTERBACKS
1. Sam Bradford, Oklahoma - 8.1
2. Colt McCoy, Texas - 6.9
3. Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame - 6.6
4. Tony Pike, Cincinnati - 5.9
5. Sean Canfield, Oregon State - 5.6
6. Tim Tebow, Florida - 4.8
7. Jevan Snead, Mississippi - 4.2
8. Dan LeFevour, Central Michigan - 3.5
9. Levi Brown, Troy - 3.2
10. Max Hall, Brigham Young - 2.9
11. Tim Hiller, Central Michigan - 2.8
12. Joe Cox, Georgia - 2.5
13. Bill Stull, Pittsburgh - 2.4
14. Darryl Clark, Penn State - 2.4
15. Jarrett Brown, West Virginia - 2.2
16. Corey Leonard, Arkansas State - 2.2
17. Mike Kafka, Northwestern - 2.1
18. Juice Williams, Illinois - 2.0
19. Thaddeus Lewis, Duke - 2.0
20. Todd Reesing, Kansas - 1.8
21. Zac Robinson, Oklahoma State - 1.6
22. Chris Todd, Auburn - 1.4
23. Greg Paulus, Syracuse - 0.9

RUNNING BACKS
1. C.J. Spiller, Clemson - 7.2
2. Jahvid Best, California - 7.0
3. Ryan Mathews, Fresno State - 6.1
4. Toby Gerhart, Stanford - 5.6
5. Jonathan Dwyer, Georgia Tech - 5.5
6. Dexter McCluster, Mississippi - 5.2
7. LeGarrette Blount, Oregon - 4.9
8. Ben Tate, Auburn - 4.4
9. Joe McKnight, USC - 4.2
10. Javarris James, Miami - 3.9
11. Chris Brown, Oklahoma - 3.8
12. Brandon Minor, Michigan - 3.7
13. Roy Upchurch, Alabama - 3.4
14. Keith Toston, Oklahoma State - 3.0
15. Trindon Holliday, LSU - 2.9
16. Shawnbrey McNeal, Southern Methodist - 2.8
17. Curtis Steele, Memphis - 2.4
18. Dimitri Nance, Arizona State - 2.2
19. Andre Dixon, Connecticut - 2.1
20. Lonyae Miller, Fresno State - 2.0
21. Reggie Arnold, Arkansas State - 1.9

FULLBACKS
1. John Conner, Kentucky - 4.8
2. Rashawn Jackson, Virginia - 4.7
3. Jack Corcoran, Rutgers - 4.6
4. Manase Tonga, Brigham Young - 4.0
5. Cory Jackson, Maryland - 2.5
6. Chris Gronkowski, Arizona - 1.6

WIDE RECEIVERS
1. Dez Bryant, Oklahoma State - 7.9
2. Arrelious Benn, Illinois - 7.1
3. Demaryius Thomas, Georgia Tech - 6.7
4. Golden Tate, Notre Dame - 6.5
5. Mardy Gilyard, Cincinnati - 6.3
6. Jordan Shipley, Texas - 6.3
7. Mike Williams, Syracuse - 6.2
8. Damian Williams, USC - 6.1
9. Dezmon Briscoe, Kansas - 5.5
10. Shay Hodge, Mississippi - 5.4
11. Eric Decker, Minnesota - 5.0
12. David Reed, Utah - 4.5
13. Danario Alexander, Missouri - 4.3
14. Brandon LaFell, LSU - 4.2
15. Riley Cooper, Florida - 4.2
16. Carlton Mitchell, South Florida - 4.0
17. Blair White, Michigan State - 3.8
18. Antonio Brown, Central Michigan - 3.7
19. Freddie Barnes, Bowling Green - 3.6
20. Emmanuel Sanders, Southern Methodist - 3.5
21. Rich Gunnell, Boston College - 3.4
22. Jacoby Ford, Clemson - 3.1
23. Alric Arnett, West Virginia - 2.9
24. Kerry Meier, Kansas - 2.8
25. Tim Brown, Rutgers - 2.3
26. Naaman Roosevelt, Buffalo - 2.2
27. Seyi Ajirotutu, Fresno State - 2.0
28. Ray Small, Ohio State - 2.0
29. Bryan Anderson, Central Michigan - 1.9
30. Carlos Singleton, Memphis - 1.7
31. Oderick Turner, Pittsburgh - 1.5


TIGHT ENDS

1. Rob Gronkowski, Arizona - 6.9
2. Jermaine Gresham, Oklahoma - 6.9
3. Aaron Hernandez, Florida - 6.8
4. Jimmy Graham, Miami - 5.9
5. Anthony McCoy, USC - 5.8
6. Ed Dickson, Oregon - 5.6
7. Tony Moeaki, Iowa - 5.4
8. Dennis Pitta, Brigham Young - 5.3
9. Garrett Graham, Wisconsin - 5.2
10. Dorin Dickerson, Pittsburgh - 4.9
11. Greg Boone, Virginia Tech - 4.7
12. Andrew Quarless, Penn State - 4.6
13. Colin Peek, Alabama - 4.1
14. Mickey Shuler, Penn State - 3.8
15. Nate Byham, Pittsburgh - 3.6
16. Steve Maneri, Temple - 3.5
17. Michael Hoomanawanui, Illinois - 3.3
18. Jeff Cumberland, Illinois - 3.1
19. Richard Dickson, LSU - 3.0
20. Jim Dray, Stanford - 2.4
21. Riar Greer, Colorado - 2.2
22. Ali Villanueva, Army - 2.0
23. Dedrick Epps, Miami - 1.9

CENTERS

1. Maurkice Pouncey, Florida - 6.9
2. J.D. Walton, Baylor - 4.9
3. Matt Tennant, Boston College - 4.5
4. Eric Olsen, Notre Dame - 4.3
5. Kevin Matthews, Texas A&M - 4.1
6. Sean Allen, East Carolina - 3.8
7. John Estes, Hawaii - 3.6
8. Ted Larsen, N.C. State - 3.2
9. Jeff Byers, USC - 3.1
10. Kenny Alfred, Washington State - 2.9
11. Robb Houser, Pittsburgh - 2.7
12. Thomas Austin, Clemson - 2.4
13. Jim Cordle, Ohio State - 2.1
14. Chris Hall, Texas - 1.9
15. Reggie Stephens, Iowa State - 1.8
16. Alonzo Durham, Nevada - 1.5
17. Andrew Lewis, Oklahoma State - 1.4

GUARDS

1. Mike Iupati, Idaho - 7.1
2. Mike Johnson, Alabama - 6.4
3. John Jerry, Mississippi - 6.2
4. Sergio Render, Virginia Tech - 5.9
5. Jon Asamoah, Illinois - 5.8
6. Kyle Calloway, Iowa - 5.4
7. Mitch Petrus, Arkansas - 5.1
8. Shawn Lauvao, Arizona State - 4.7
9. John Malecki, Pittsburgh - 4.4
10. Joe Thomas, Pittsburgh - 4.2
11. Zane Beadles, Utah - 4.1
12. Brandon Carter, Texas Tech - 3.7
13. Brian Simmons, Oklahoma - 3.6
14. Marshall Newhouse, Texas Christian - 3.4
15. Kurtis Gregory, Missouri - 3.2
16. Vince Vance, Georgia - 2.9
17. Chris Marinelli, Stanford - 2.0

OFFENSIVE TACKLES

1. Russell Okung, Oklahoma State - 8.4
2. Bryan Bulaga, Iowa - 8.2
3. Trent Williams, Oklahoma - 7.8
4. Charles Brown, USC - 7.4
5. Anthony Davis, Rutgers - 6.8
6. Bruce Campbell, Maryland - 5.8
7. Jason Fox, Miami - 5.2
8. Ciron Black, LSU - 4.9
9. Selvish Capers, West Virginia - 4.9
10. Rodger Saffold, Indiana - 4.5
11. Ed Wang, Virginia Tech - 3.9
12. Mike Tepper, California - 3.7
13. Will Barker, Virginia - 3.5
14. Sam Young, Notre Dame - 3.4
15. Kevin Haslam, Rutgers - 3.1
16. Adam Ulatoski, Texas - 2.5
17. Jeff Linkenbach, Cincinnati - 2.4
18. Dennis Landolt, Penn State - 1.9
19. Drew Davis, Alabama - 1.7
20. Kyle Jolly, North Carolina - 1.5

Scroll down for defensive rankings.

_________________
"Vincere scis, Hannibal, victoria uti nescis" -- Maharbal, 216 B.C.E.


Top
 Profile E-mail  
 
 Post subject: Re: Pudge's Positional Rankings (Offense)
PostPosted: Sun Apr 04, 2010 7:09 pm 
Offline
Moderator
Moderator
User avatar

Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2005 7:02 pm
Posts: 6566
Location: Indianapolis IN
I'd have to agree with the assessment. Rob G out of Arizona wish the falcon's had a shot at him but he'll likely go top 10 in the 2nd round.I think the kid from Miami could be a good developmental player.

_________________
Sometimes running the Mularkey offense makes me feel like I'm in a prison.


Top
 Profile E-mail  
 
 Post subject: Re: Pudge's Positional Rankings (Defense)
PostPosted: Mon Apr 05, 2010 1:57 am 
Offline
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
User avatar

Joined: Thu Dec 23, 2004 3:03 pm
Posts: 25930
Location: North Carolina
DEFENSIVE ENDS

1. Derrick Morgan, Georgia Tech - 8.4
2. Brandon Graham, Michigan - 7.4
3. Jason Pierre-Paul, South Florida - 6.6
4. Everson Griffen, USC - 6.2
5. Corey Wootton, Northwestern - 5.7
6. Greg Hardy, Mississippi - 5.1
7. Carlos Dunlap, Florida - 5.0
8. E.J. Wilson, North Carolina - 4.4
9. Jermaine Cunningham, Florida - 4.3
10. Alex Carrington, Arkansas State - 4.2
11. Will Tukuafu, Oregon - 3.9
12. George Selvie, South Florida - 3.8
13. Brandon Lang, Troy - 3.7
14. Jan Jorgensen, Brigham Young - 3.5
15. Erik Lorig, Stanford - 3.4
16. C.J. Wilson, East Carolina - 3.1
17. Antonio Coleman, Auburn - 3.0
18. Jammie Kirlew, Indiana - 2.9
19. Lindsey Witten, Connecticut - 2.7
20. Frank Zombo, Central Michigan - 2.6
21. Kevin Basped, Nevada - 2.5
22. Greg Middleton, Indiana - 2.4
23. Brandon Sharpe, Texas Tech - 2.4
24. Nekos Brown, Virginia Tech - 2.3
25. John Fletcher, Wyoming - 2.1
26. Daniel Te'o-Nesheim, Washington - 2.0
27. Eric Moncur, Miami - 1.9
28. Alex Daniels, Cincinnati - 1.9
28. Lawrence Wilson, Ohio State - 1.8
29. Doug Pilcher, Illinois - 1.6
30. Maxwell Onyegbule, Kansas - 1.5
31. John Fonoti, Hawaii - 1.5

DEFENSIVE TACKLES

1. Ndamukong Suh, Nebraska - 8.8
2. Gerald McCoy, Oklahoma -8.7
3. Jared Odrick, Penn State - 6.9
4. Brian Price, UCLA - 6.5
5. Terrence Cody, Alabama - 6.4
6. Tyson Alualu, California - 6.3
7. Arthur Jones, Syracuse - 5.6
8. Lamarr Houston, Texas - 5.0
9. Jeff Owens, Georgia - 4.9
10. Geno Atkins, Georgia - 4.8
11. Cam Thomas, North Carolina - 4.7
12. Torrell Troup, Central Florida - 4.6
13. D'Anthony Smith, Louisiana Tech - 4.5
14. Brandon Deaderick, Alabama - 4.0
15. Corey Peters, Kentucky - 3.9
16. Mick Williams, Pittsburgh - 3.8
17. Kade Weston, Georgia - 3.7
18. Doug Worthington, Ohio State - 3.7
19. Linval Joseph, East Carolina - 3.6
20. DeMarcus Granger, Oklahoma - 3.6
21. Vince Oghobaase, Duke - 3.1
22. Jay Ross, East Carolina - 3.1
23. Jake Ricks, Auburn - 2.9
24. Alan-Michael Cash, N.C. State - 2.8
25. Aleric Mullins, North Carolina - 2.8
26. Cordarrow Thompson, Virginia Tech - 2.7
27. Lorenzo Washington, Alabama - 2.6
28. Swanson Miller, Oklahoma State - 2.6
29. Boo Robinson, Wake Forest - 2.5
30. Earl Mitchell, Arizona - 2.4
31. John Russell, Wake Forest - 2.3
32. Andre Neblett, Temple - 2.0
32. Ekom Udofia, Stanford - 1.8
33. Travis Ivey, Maryland - 1.7
34. Jaron Baston, Missouri - 1.5
35. Ricardo Mathews, Cincinnati - 1.5
36. Kendrick Stewart, Florida State - 1.4

Yet to See: Dan Williams, Tennessee

OUTSIDE LINEBACKERS

1. Sean Weatherspoon, Missouri - 7.3
2. Eric Norwood, South Carolina - 6.9
3. Jerry Hughes, Texas Christian - 6.5
4. Rennie Curran, Georgia - 6.2
5. Jason Worilds, Virginia Tech - 6.0
6. Sergio Kindle, Texas - 5.9
7. Koa Misi, Utah - 5.7
8. Ricky Sapp, Clemson - 5.4
9. Navorro Bowman, Cincinnati - 5.3
10. Thaddeus Gibson, Ohio State - 5.2
11. O'Brien Schofield, Wisconsin - 5.1
12. A.J. Edds, Iowa - 5.0
13. Roddrick Muckleroy, Texas - 4.9
14. Stevenson Sylvester, Utah - 4.7
15. Willie Young, N.C. State - 4.4
16. Dekoda Watson, Florida State - 4.3
17. Keenan Clayton, Oklahoma - 3.9
18. Perry Riley, LSU - 3.5
19. Simoni Lawrence, Minnesota - 3.4
20. Cameron Sheffield, Troy - 3.0
21. Denzell Burrell, Virginia - 2.9
22. Travis Goethel, Arizona State - 2.8
23. Dexter Davis, Arizona State - 2.7
24. Keaton Kristick, Oregon State - 2.7
25. Kavell Conner, Clemson - 2.6
26. Cody Grimm, Virginia Tech - 2.4
27. Brian Coulter, Missouri - 2.1
28. Andy Mattingly, Washington State - 2.1
29. Chris McCoy, Middle Tennessee - 2.0

Yet to See: Rico McCoy, Tennessee

INSIDE LINEBACKERS

1. Rolando McClain, Alabama - 8.8
2. Sean Lee, Penn State - 6.0
3. Daryl Washington, Texas Christian - 5.9
4. Brandon Spikes, Florida - 5.8
5. Joe Pawelek, Baylor - 5.0
6. Darryl Sharpton, Miami - 4.8
7. Pat Angerer, Iowa - 4.7
8. Kion Wilson, South Florida - 4.3
9. Clinton Snyder, Stanford - 4.2
10. Boris Lee, Troy - 3.5
11. Josh Hull, Penn State - 3.3
12. Micah Johnson, Kentucky - 3.0
13. Reggie Carter, UCLA - 2.9
14. Donald Butler, Washington - 2.8
15. Reed Williams, West Virginia - 2.5
16. Donald Booker, Oklahoma State - 2.4
17. Mike McLaughlin, Boston College - 2.2
18. Bear Woods, Troy - 2.1
19. Matt Mayberry, Indiana - 2.0
20. Vincent Rey, Duke - 1.9
21. Jon Dempsey, Louisville - 1.8
22. Ryan D'Imperio, Rutgers - 1.7
23. Danny Carmichael, Middle Tennessee - 1.4

CORNERBACKS

1. Joe Haden, Florida - 8.6
2. Kyle Wilson, Boise State - 7.0
3. Kareem Jackson, Alabama - 6.8
4. Patrick Robinson, Florida State - 6.5
5. Perrish Cox, Oklahoma State - 6.1
6. Walter Thurmond, Oregon - 5.7
7. Syd'Quan Thompson, California - 5.6
8. Trevard Lindley, Kentucky - 5.3
9. Dominique Franks, Oklahoma - 5.0
10. Brandon Ghee, Wake Forest - 4.9
11. Donovan Warren, Michigan - 4.8
12. Devin McCourty, Rutgers - 4.6
13. Jerome Murphy, South Florida - 4.5
14. Brian Jackson, Oklahoma - 4.1
15. Javier Arenas, Alabama - 3.9
16. Chris Cook, Virginia - 3.9
17. Sherrick McManis, Northwestern - 3.4
18. Devin Ross, Arizona - 3.1
19. Marquis Johnson, Alabama - 3.0
19. Jamar Wall, Texas Tech - 2.9
20. Chris Chancellor, Clemson - 2.8
21. Kevin Thomas, USC - 2.8
22. Crezdon Butler, Clemson - 2.4
23. A.J. Jefferson, Fresno State - 2.3
24. Stephan Virgil, Virginia Tech - 2.2
25. Alterraun Verner, UCLA - 2.1
26. Chris Hawkins, LSU - 1.9
27. Aaron Berry, Pittsburgh - 1.7

SAFETIES

1. Eric Berry, Tennessee*
2. Earl Thomas, Texas - 8.2
3. Morgan Burnett, Georgia Tech - 5.8
4. Nate Allen, South Florida - 5.4
5. Kam Chancellor, Virginia Tech - 5.3
6. Chad Jones, LSU - 5.2
7. Taylor Mays, USC - 5.1
8. Major Wright, Florida - 5.0
9. T.J. Ward, Oregon - 4.9
10. Myron Rolle, Florida State - 4.8
11. Reshad Jones, Georgia - 4.6
12. Justin Woodall, Alabama - 4.4
13. Kurt Coleman, Ohio State - 4.3
14. Darrell Stuckey, Kansas - 4.2
15. Larry Asante, Nebraska - 3.8
16. Robert Johnson, Utah - 3.6
17. Barry Church, Toledo - 3.4
18. Dorian Porch, Virginia Tech - 2.5
19. Van Eskridge, East Carolina - 2.4
20. Andre Sexton, Oklahoma State - 2.2
21. Aaron Webster, Cincinnati - 2.1
22. Bo McNally, Stanford - 2.1
23. Jordan Lake, Baylor - 1.9
24. Terrell Skinner, Maryland - 1.4
25. Jamie Robinson, Florida State - 1.2

KICKERS

1. Leigh Tiffin, Alabama - 2.5
2. Hunter Lawrence, Texas - 2.4
3. Brett Swenson, Michigan State - 2.2
4. Joshua Shene, Mississippi - 1.7
5. Andrew Aguila, Central Michigan - 1.2

PUNTERS

1. Zoltan Mesko, Michigan - 2.6
2. Jeremy Boone, Penn State - 2.5
3. Matt Dodge, East Carolina - 2.5
4. Brent Bowden, Virginia Tech - 2.4
5. Mike Brandtner, Iowa State - 1.4
6. Robert Malone, Fresno State - 1.3

LONG SNAPPERS

1. Mike Windt, Cincinnati - 2.1
2. Clint Gresham, Texas Christian - 1.6
3. Jack Geiser, Boston College - 1.0

_________________
"Vincere scis, Hannibal, victoria uti nescis" -- Maharbal, 216 B.C.E.


Top
 Profile E-mail  
 
 Post subject: Re: Pudge's Positional Rankings
PostPosted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 4:49 am 
Offline
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
User avatar

Joined: Thu Dec 23, 2004 3:03 pm
Posts: 25930
Location: North Carolina
Bump for the ratings added to offensive players.

_________________
"Vincere scis, Hannibal, victoria uti nescis" -- Maharbal, 216 B.C.E.


Top
 Profile E-mail  
 
 Post subject: Re: Pudge's Positional Rankings
PostPosted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 11:32 pm 
Offline
Superstar
Superstar
User avatar

Joined: Sun Sep 09, 2007 5:41 pm
Posts: 2393
Location: Albany NY
Damn Pudge you've gone all out this year with your draft scouting, nice work... Where do you find the time, this must take forever to compile

_________________
When life gives you lemons, find some salt and tequila then invite me!


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject: Re: Pudge's Positional Rankings
PostPosted: Thu Apr 08, 2010 11:51 pm 
Offline
Moderator
Moderator
User avatar

Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2005 7:02 pm
Posts: 6566
Location: Indianapolis IN
If we go another position in the 1st(not def end) I'd like to see the Falcon's take a flier on Hardy from Mississippi in the 3rd. Maybe he'll mature and with good coaching could do something. I still like Graham with an ouside shot at Spoon since def end is more of a priority than linebacker or should I say a more impact position. If both players are rated fairly high I think Spoon or Graham wil be the pick.

Wow you have Odrick pretty low.I'm not to fond of Penn State def lineman either.It's possible Renie Curran could be taken in the 3rd by the Falcon's. I see you have Moeaki generally where the Falcon's could draft him in the 4th round. Matt Tenant looks like according to your rankinbgs Pudge a possible 3rd round pick also.It would be nice to have John Jerry but he looks like a 2nd round pick.I'd like a project off lineman either guard/tackle not sure if Reynolds can be a fulltime starter in the future for Atlanta now.We need to prepare for after this coming year having a few free agent off linemen.I don't see alot of talent ready to step in.

_________________
Sometimes running the Mularkey offense makes me feel like I'm in a prison.


Top
 Profile E-mail  
 
 Post subject: Re: Pudge's Positional Rankings
PostPosted: Sat Apr 10, 2010 4:57 am 
Offline
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
Purveyor of Truth & Justice
User avatar

Joined: Thu Dec 23, 2004 3:03 pm
Posts: 25930
Location: North Carolina
Bump for defensive ratings.

_________________
"Vincere scis, Hannibal, victoria uti nescis" -- Maharbal, 216 B.C.E.


Top
 Profile E-mail  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 7 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 4 hours [ DST ]


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Jump to: