LT has to grade out a little higher than Vick at this point. Vick graded higher a couple of years ago...but this past years inconsistency dropped his stock substansially. One solid season from Vick though, and it could tip the other way.
Vick & The Falcons: 02 NFC Wild Card & NFC Divisional Game, 04 Divisional Game & NFC Championship Game
LT & The Bolts: 04 Wild Card Game
At the end of the day the measure of a players value is whether or not they win championships and was core piece of a playoff contender. If you take Vick off this squad and put LT on this squad I got money that says the Falcons have 1 WC loss vs 4 Playoff games.
Vick may not be the most refined Quarterback in the league but he is among the most dangerous weapons to strap on cleats.